Diabetes Is Not One Disease

World Diabetes Day – 14 November

In 1922, in a children’s ward at a Toronto hospital, Frederick Banting and Charles Best moved from bed to bed injecting a newly purified extract into children who were deeply comatose and wasting away.

Most of the children lay still under the sheets, and their parents sat nearby, having already been told there was little left to do.

As the two men worked their way through the room, the first children began to stir. By the time they reached the far end of the ward, several of those injected earlier had opened their eyes and started to sit up, looking around in quiet confusion. The parents, who had been waiting in silence, reached for their children as the room slowly filled with the sound of voices and movement that no one had expected to ever hear again.

The extract? Insulin from the pancreas of cattle. The disease: type 1 diabetes. Up to that moment, a death sentence.

Spending on Others or on Yourself

We often think of diabetes as a modern lifestyle disease, but it is one of the oldest described diseases in the world and not unique to any area.

An Egyptian papyrus from around 1550 BC, the Ebers Papyrus, describes a condition of excessive urination.

More than two thousand years ago, the Indian physicians Sushruta and Charaka noticed that ants were drawn to the urine of certain patients. They called it “madhumeha”, which translates into “honey urine”.

Sushruta also noted it was most common among the wealthy, who ate a great deal of rice, cereals and sweets.

Around 250 BC, Apollonius of Memphis used the word “diabetes”. It comes from the Greek diabainein, “to pass through”, the word for a siphon: water seemed to run straight through the body.

Aretaeus of Cappadocia later described the disease as a melting of flesh into urine, with short survival.

In 1675, the English physician Thomas Willis added “mellitus”, honey-sweet, after tasting his patients’ urine, and in 1776 Matthew Dobson showed that the sweetness was sugar.

For the next century and a half, the only treatment for young patients was a near-starvation diet that bought months, not years. That ward in Toronto ended that era.

The Blame Game

Diabetes has been simplified in many modern conversations into two types, and where type 1 is seen as no fault of your own, type 2 is “because you’ve not looked after yourself”. This simplistic take is largely not the full story.

Type 1 is not always autoimmune. Type 1b, or idiopathic type 1, shows no immune antibodies and is seen more often in people of African and Asian ancestry. Ketosis-prone diabetes, common in West Africa, arrives like type 1 with a dangerous ketoacidosis crisis, yet many people later come off insulin.

Some cancer immunotherapy drugs can trigger type 1 within months. Viral infections, especially enteroviruses, are strongly linked to its onset. Genes load the gun; something else often pulls the trigger.

Type 2 is not simply a lifestyle verdict. Twin and family studies attribute 40 to 70% of type 2 risk to inherited factors.

When one identical twin has it, the other does about 70% of the time, compared with 20 to 30% in non-identical twins.

Having one parent with type 2 gives a lifetime risk of about 40%; two parents, about 70%. In Africa, roughly two in five people with type 2 diabetes are not overweight.

Their main problem is a pancreas that releases too little insulin, not excess body fat.

In South Africa, diabetes was the leading natural cause of death in 2024, at 79 people a day, and about 73% of adults with diabetes in Africa don’t know they have it. Blame doesn’t find those people. Testing does.

Add steroid and HIV medication, short sleep, prolonged overload with no recovery, shift work and a hungry childhood, and the “your fault” story falls apart.

Diabetes is actually a range of many, more complex, illnesses.

There Are at Least Nine Kinds of Diabetes

Several types of diabetes have no causal link with each other at all. They share a result, not a cause: too much glucose stays in the blood.

Contributors can be autoimmune, genetic, nutritional, surgical, hormonal or drug-related. The old name, “sweet siphon”, describes what happens but not why. When every type is treated as the same disease, people get the wrong advice.

  • Type 1: The pancreas makes little or no insulin, usually because the immune system has destroyed the insulin-producing cells.
  • LADA (“type 1.5”): This slow autoimmune form appears in adults and is often first mistaken for type 2.
  • Type 2: This is the most common type. The body resists insulin, makes too little of it, or both.
  • Gestational: This type develops during pregnancy, usually resolves after birth, and raises the later risk of type 2.
  • Type 3 (Alzheimer’s disease): Researchers use this proposed term because in Alzheimer’s the brain becomes resistant to insulin and appears to make less of it, leaving nerve cells short of fuel.
  • Type 3c: This type is unrelated to type 3. It describes a condition where something else damages the pancreas as a whole: pancreatitis, pancreatic cancer, cystic fibrosis, iron overload (haemochromatosis) or surgery.
  • Type 5: The International Diabetes Federation recognised this type only in April 2025. Chronic undernutrition in childhood and adolescence leaves the pancreas unable to make enough insulin. It affects an estimated 20 to 25 million people, mainly lean young adults in Asia and sub-Saharan Africa.

  • MODY and neonatal diabetes: A single faulty gene causes these forms. MODY alone has more than ten subtypes.
  • Drug-induced: Medicines such as corticosteroids, some antipsychotics, some HIV medicines and transplant drugs can trigger it.

Lifestyle Helps Every Type, but It Is Not Always the Whole Answer

In the Diabetes Prevention Program, people with prediabetes who lost 5 to 7% of their weight and walked briskly for 150 minutes a week cut their risk of type 2 by 58%.

In the DiRECT trial, 46% of people with recent type 2 diabetes were in remission a year after a structured weight-loss programme. The same trial also shows the limit: by five years, only about 13% remained in remission, as weight returned and the pancreas kept ageing.

In type 1, regular exercise lowers HbA1c and reduces daily insulin needs, and better control protects the heart, eyes and kidneys.

In type 3 (Alzheimer’s), movement, diet, alcohol reduction and gut health can bring inspiring improvements, and regular heat therapy such as sauna use is associated with a lower risk of dementia, though cause is not yet proven.

In type 3c and MODY, food and movement improve control, but they cannot rebuild a damaged pancreas or rewrite a gene.

Those patients need insulin or a specific medicine, and needing it is not a failure.

In type 5, good nourishment is the backbone of care, but insulin must be handled with great care because these patients can drop dangerously low.

Lifestyle improves the outcome in every type. Needing medicine as well says nothing about willpower.

Diabetes Risk Rises with Age, but You Can Lower It

Getting older does not cause diabetes by itself, but it changes the body in ways that make several types more likely.

  • Type 2: The insulin-producing cells of the pancreas release less insulin as we age, even in lean people. Muscle normally takes up most of the glucose from a meal, and we lose muscle from middle age onwards unless we use it. Fat also shifts towards the abdomen and liver.
  • Type 1 and LADA: These are not only childhood diseases. In a large UK study, 42% of people with genetically confirmed type 1 diabetes developed it between the ages of 31 and 60, and many were first treated as type 2. LADA, by definition, starts in adulthood.
  • Type 3 (Alzheimer’s): Age is the strongest single risk factor for Alzheimer’s disease, and insulin resistance in the brain becomes more common as we get older.
  • Type 3c: Pancreatitis and pancreatic cancer both become more common with age. New diabetes after 50 deserves a closer look: about 1 in 100 people diagnosed at this age are found to have pancreatic cancer within three years. Unexplained weight loss alongside rising blood sugar is a reason to ask for more tests.
  • Drug-induced: Most people take more medicines as they age. Statins raise the risk of new diabetes by about 9%, and steroids and some blood-pressure tablets (thiazide diuretics) also raise blood sugar. Review them with your doctor rather than stopping them on your own. Age is no reason to give up. In the Diabetes Prevention Program, the lifestyle programme worked best in people aged 60 and older, cutting their risk of type 2 by 71%.

  • Build and keep muscle: Strength training two or three times a week improves insulin sensitivity in people over 60. Carry your own shopping, climb stairs, use resistance bands and practise standing up from a chair without using your hands.
  • Eat to protect muscle and the pancreas: Choose real, high-fibre food with enough protein and keep refined starch, sugar and alcohol low.
  • Keep moving through the day: Break up sitting and walk after meals. The exercise snacks described below work at every age.
  • Protect the brain: In the Finnish FINGER trial, older adults at risk who combined a healthy diet, exercise, brain training and control of blood pressure and blood sugar kept their thinking skills better than those who did not.
  • Test regularly: Check fasting glucose and insulin from 40, or earlier if diabetes runs in your family, and repeat the tests every few years as you get older.

Supplements Can Actually Push Blood Sugar Health the Wrong Way

There is a reason Hoogland’s approach is diet first. A bad diet cannot be out-supplemented. Supplements can contribute to real harm. Supplements should only be used to top up what is genuinely low. Several popular supplements can raise blood sugar or speed up diabetes:

  • Vitamin B3 (niacin): Doctors once prescribed high doses to raise “good” cholesterol. Across 11 trials with more than 26,000 people, niacin raised the risk of new diabetes by 34%: one extra case for every 43 people taking it for five years. It also worsens control in people who already have diabetes.
  • Iron: High body iron stores (ferritin) are linked to about 70% higher risk of type 2 diabetes, and severe iron overload damages the pancreas outright. Taking iron without a proven deficiency only adds to the store.
  • Selenium: It is sold as an antioxidant, but trials have hinted at a higher risk of type 2 diabetes, and that risk has not been ruled out.
  • “Herbal” remedies with hidden steroids: Laboratory testing in Tanzania found dexamethasone and prednisolone in herbal medicines on sale. Steroids raise blood glucose directly, and a hidden one can tip a borderline person into diabetes.

Stress Helps in Short Bursts but Harms When It Never Switches Off

Stress is a caring response. When something matters to you, adrenaline and cortisol release glucose so your muscles and brain have fuel to meet the challenge.

The trouble starts when the response runs for months with no recovery and no movement to use the fuel. The liver keeps releasing glucose, and the cells slowly become less sensitive to insulin.

A 2022 analysis of 18 studies found that people in high-strain jobs, with heavy demands and little control, had a 16% higher risk of type 2 diabetes. Where effort went unrewarded, the risk was 24% higher.

Exercise snacks undo much of this. In a 2012 study, simply standing up for a two-minute walk every 20 minutes of sitting lowered the after-meal rise in glucose by about 25 to 29% and insulin by about 23%.

Poorly managed stress can also contribute to developing and worsening type 3 and type 3c diabetes.

Act Early and Know Your Numbers

World Diabetes Day falls on 14 November, Banting’s birthday, and this year’s theme is early action.

Fasting glucose and insulin tests are a great start. Test HbA1c (a marker of average blood sugar over several weeks) if either of those is elevated.

A glucose-tolerance test with paired insulin readings, which we offer at Hoogland, shows how your body handles sugar over two hours and can reveal insulin resistance years before a diagnosis.

Whatever your type, movement, real food, sleep, recovery from stress and the right medicine where needed all improve the outcome.

None of it is about blame.

All of it is about acting early.

Further Reading

  1. University of Toronto. The Discovery and Early Development of Insulin.
    collections.library.utoronto.ca/explore/insulin
  2. International Diabetes Federation. Type 5 diabetes.
    idf.org/about-diabetes/type-5-diabetes
  3. IDF Diabetes Atlas, 11th edition, 2025.
    diabetesatlas.org
  4. Atypical diabetes subtypes in Black African populations. Diabetologia, 2026.
    doi.org/10.1007/s00125-026-06697-3
  5. Knowler et al. Diabetes Prevention Program. N Engl J Med, 2002.
    pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1282458
  6. Lean et al. DiRECT: diet-led remission of type 2 diabetes. The Lancet, 2018.
    directclinicaltrial.org.uk
  7. Goldie et al. Niacin therapy and the risk of new-onset diabetes. Heart, 2016.
  8. Pena-Gralle et al. Work stressors and type 2 diabetes. Scand J Work Environ Health, 2022.
    pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8729162
  9. Dunstan et al. Breaking up prolonged sitting reduces glucose and insulin. Diabetes Care, 2012.
  10. Sattar et al. Statins and risk of incident diabetes. The Lancet, 2010.
    eprints.gla.ac.uk/36704
  11. Stats SA. Mortality and causes of death in South Africa, 2024.
    statssa.gov.za

 

Go to Top